We said we were going to review stuff............... so here's my first attempt:
When is this genre going to tire out? Apparently not anytime soon, if sales are any gauge of general public demand. The Arctic Monkey's debut cd, Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I Am Not, has been out for about 3 or 4 weeks in the UK and a little less than a week in the US. In this time span it has sales approaching 400,000 copies, which is entirely amazing given the state of the music industry in modern times. These kinds of early sales are in the league of the great (cough) fiddy and (vomit) Mariah Carey.
Not being from England, I have no idea how this album was promoted in that country. I know, for instance, that in the US I've never once heard an Arctic Monkeys song on the radio. But, from what I've read, this band got famous mostly on internet buzz, free downloading, and demo tapes passed out at live shows. And still the music industry insists that downloading hurts the musicians.
The Arctic Monkeys, upon first listen, sound similar to bands such as the Strokes and the Libertines. Yes they have a different singer, and yes the guitars are little more fierce, but is this really a new sound? The answer, of course, is no. But it doesn't matter, because the album is filled with hooks and catchy lyrics that are very friendly upon first listen. In many respects this band is very similar to the Killers and Franz Ferdinand, and it only seems to be a matter of time before they catch on as strongly in the US as they have in the UK.
Take for instance the track "Fake Tales of San Francisco." The bass groove/ drum beat in the background could have come straight out of a Killers album. While it's not as lyrically infectious as something like Mr. Brightside or Somebody Told Me, it still is a great song that demands repeat listens. Artistically it trumps the work of the Killers, but still it is too safe to compare to the level of intensity found on songs from (as an example) The Libertines' Self-titled. But again, this is a debut, so you must remember to be more lenient with regard to matters such as these.
As for the rest of the songs, they have varying degrees of success. I love the opener, The View from the Afternoon. Again, it feels like I've heard this song a dozen different times, but the Arctic Monkeys pull it off well. Pounding drums in the beginning transform into a searing dance punk guitar rhythm backed by Helder pounding the high-hat at a Rapturisk tempo.
Where my view probably differs from a lot of other people is in the second song "I Bet You Look Good on the Dancefloor." I honestly think this song is a totally failure. It really pisses me off when you make a song about a dancefloor and it is totally undanceable. It starts off with some guitar wankery, James Cook showing some skill as he fiddles with his whammy bar. Eventually the song settles down into a quick tempo beat that is catchy. Alex Turner sings "Oh you're an explosion" with a crazed "You're dynomite!" sung in the background. Then suddenly the song changes tempo to an even quicker beat with Turner yelling "Oh I bet that you look good on the dancefloor/I don't know if you looking for romance or/ I don't know what you are lookin' for." This part is fucking impossible to dance to. Go ahead and try it, you won't be able to successfully do it without looking foolish. I can't understand what their goal is here. Do they want a dance song or a mosh pit number? Eventually they resort to that intro guitar solo with Helder's wailing on the drums and finish the song on what most would call (but not me) a rockin note. This song just doesn't fit with the rest of the songs on the album.
Many of the other songs succeed where this song failed. "Dancing Shoes" is a great song as is "You Probably Couldn't See for the Lights But You Were Standing Straight at Me." These songs have true vision and don't go off into an unnecessary guitar/ drum explosion. One of the best songs is number 6, "Still Take You Home," where band keeps the intensity level raised with the best guitar jam yet, drawing you more deeply into the album.
Overall the album is pretty even with maybe only the closer looking like another possible weak point. This song comes off as a little too much of a Libertines impression in my opinion, but it is likely to be pleasing even after repeat listens. Still it isn't the strong closer you'd hope for in a album such as this one. In one respect they win by going out following the winning formula they established with the first 12 songs (minus song 2), but in another respect they fail in that they don't offer anything new and uplifting for the end. More often than not I find myself skipping this final song to put the player back to the beginning of the album.
So, an impressive debut definitely. This band is sure to continue to draw in a legion of fans because they make music to suite the masses. Understandably they live in the shadow of the bands they imitate, but I look forward to seeing if they can clearly break the mold with their next album.
Score: 7/10
Here's a track that isn't on the album, cause I'm sure most of you already have the album.
Arctic Monkeys - Cigarette Smoke